Writers get conflicting advice from all sides: from readers, from professionals, from critters. You know the story you want to tell and how you want to tell it. Some people will get what you're doing and some won't. Here is a list of things your work should have regardless of feedback:♥ complex characters (check out this example of character developmentand how to use it to find plot points)
♥ a strong voice (check out this post on voice)
♥ a story question that doesn't lose slack until at least the climax (check out this post to learn about story questions)
♥ conflict (check out this post on conflicts)
♥ a solid, beginning, middle and end with no saggy, draggy parts (check out these posts for more on beginnings, middles and ends)
♥ hooks in the story and at the end of chapters. (check out this post on hooks)
♥ strong verbs (check out this post on weak verbs)
♥ dialogue that reveals character and/or moves the story forward (check out this post on dialogue)
♥ dimension, description and sensory impressions (check out this post on visceral depth)
Also use good grammar, zingy prose and the appropriate narrative for the story.
A professional who read a partial suggested Kings & Queens would be better served in First Person with just my MC's perspective, but my story's complexity in the next two-thirds of the book would be completely lost in such a limited scope. Some stories work perfectly in First, and some of my future works are calling to be told in First, but this one would be severly damaged and empty. My forty-three other readers would hunt me down with hatchets if I even considered taking out the guys. I can't imagine my book without Derek's perspective or Warren's; they help to paint the full scope of the plot and show how they break their stereotypes.
If my story were just about a church shooting and the girl who overheard the plot beforehand, as it appers at the onset, maybe First Person could work, but it grows and grows and grows into something totally unexpected and twisted, and my main character, Majesty, is not aware of that aspect of the plot until the very end.
You know the story you want to tell, so tell it in the way that's right for the story. Trust your gut.
~ Signing off and sending out cyber hugs.









